American Spirits
February 23, 2001: A Very Special Evening

Labrot & Graham Distillery
Versailles, Kentucky


On July 29, 2000 Labrot & Graham hosted the inaugural dinner and reception of the newly-formed Kentucky chapter of the American Institute of Wine and Food at the distillery. The speaker and guest of honor was Julia Child. Building upon the success of that evening, the distillery began sending invitations and brochures to select customers and patrons, announcing a whole series of special events, called the Bourbon & Bluegrass Series, to be held later that year and into spring of 2001. There would be a Christmas celebration, a bourbon and chocolate tasting, cooking classes, and a series of Master Distiller’s Table events, the first of which would be presented on Friday, February 23rd. Unlike the daily distillery tours, these events are not free and, although open to the public, are by reservation only. To learn more, call them at 1-859-879-1812 or write to

Labrot & Graham Distillery
7855 McCracken Pike
Versailles, Kentucky 40383

THIS AFTERNOON WE LEAVE from our Lexington motel in what we expect will be plenty of time to get to the Labrot & Graham distillery for the special event beginning at 5:30 this evening. We thought we might take a ride past Stone Castle, the Old Taylor distillery which is not far from Labrot & Graham, to see if the antique shop there might still be open. The owner, Cecil Withrow, passed away last December and we thought we might offer our condolences to his wife. We drive to Versailles, but we just can’t find Elm Street, the road that becomes McCracken Pike as it heads toward Glenn’s Creek. After driving out the other side of Versailles and turning around, we drive back to the intersection at the center of town and take another road. As that one starts heading off into unfamiliar territory, we turn around and do it all over again. Back and forth. Around and around. We stop and ask directions (Linda’s idea) (of course), then follow the directions; then end up right back where we started from. None of the roads seem to lead past the Catholic school that has always been our landmark for locating Elm. After a frustrating hour and half of driving around and around Versailles (never mind Old Taylor; we’re now nearly half an hour late for the event), Linda finally spots Elm Street. Looking over, John sees that they’ve remodeled the Catholic school, adding a fence and other features that has caused us to drive right by several times without noticing it. We arrive at Labrot & Graham frustrated and embarrassed, only to discover that they’ve wisely allowed some lead time and we aren’t too late after all. In fact, there will be others who will arrive after us.

As we enter the Visitor’s Center, we are offered hors d’oeuvres and bourbon before joining about fifteen other people milling around and talking with Bill Creason (Labrot & Graham’s general manager and our host this evening), Dave Scheurich (the plant manager and on-site distiller), Lincoln Henderson (Brown-Forman’s master distiller), Jimmy Russell (Wild Turkey’s master distiller), and Sam Thomas (one of Kentucky’s best-known bourbon historians), Both Jimmy and Lincoln seem to remember us from times we’ve met them before. Also among the guests is Marnie Walters, the young woman John spoke to on the phone for reservations, who shares a very beautiful and unusual name with John’s daughter.

Not long afterward (it’s too bad we were so late, this party itself must have lasted nearly an hour), Bill announces that the tour is about to begin. We are encouraged to freshen our drinks and bring them with us. We board the tour bus that takes guests from the Visitor Center down into the hollow where the distillery itself lies. After leaving the bus, we assemble in front of the main distillery building and the tour commences.Lincoln Henderson tells L & G history

In many ways, of course, the tour is like the normal public tours. After all, the same things are being covered. But this tour is being presented with a running commentary by a pair of the most expert tour guides imaginable, Lincoln Henderson and Jimmy Russell. Having these two gentlemen present the tour brings out angles and points of view that would never have been touched without them. In fact, the two of them playing off one another provides insights that could only have occurred here and now.

Of course, the tour begins with a discussion of the distillery’s history. These buildings were originally the Elijah Pepper distillery, the home of master distiller James Crow. Crow is generally recognized as one of the founding fathers of the bourbon industry as we know it, and many think of him as the father of bourbon itself. The distillery passed though several hands before becoming the Labrot & Graham distillery in 1878, which it remained even after being sold to Brown-Forman in 1941. In the early 1960’s it was sold and shut down. It lay abandoned and decaying for years before they bought it back again and spent nearly ten million dollars restoring it to its current state. As Lincoln was pointing this out, John mentions Charles K. Cowdery’s videotape, made in 1991 and aired on Kentucky public television, that shows scenes of the distillery in its abandonment. Lincoln thanks him for bringing it up and takes an opportunity to praise Chuck’s program.Jimmy Russell and Bill Creason

Labrot & Graham is unique among all bourbon distilleries, not only because of it’s place in bourbon history but also for the three gorgeous copper pot stills that are it’s heart and soul. Jimmy Russell’s Boulevard Distillery, better known throughout the world as Wild Turkey, is also steeped in bourbon history, but his whiskey is distilled in what is known as a "continuous still". This is the type used by every other bourbon distillery, and the one at Wild Turkey is a first-class example of that type. There are many other differences as well, such as who makes their barrels (there are only two companies; Labrot & Graham uses Bluegrass Cooperage and Wild Turkey uses Independent Stave Company – and each swears their choice of barrel is a contributing factor in their success), the exact combination of corn, rye, and barley malt (they won’t tell, other than to say that they don’t tell anybody and printed reports they’ve seen are both fictitious and wrong), and the type of warehouses they use for aging the bourbon (Labrot & Graham uses unique stone warehouses with controlled temperature; Wild Turkey uses metal-clad warehouses with natural temperatures). In fact, nearly everything about their approach to making fine bourbon whiskey is different between the two, but both agree that the result is still fine bourbon.

Lincoln Henderson and Jimmy RussellSo, as we progress through the distillery, we learn how the whiskey here is made, as well as how that’s different from the way it’s made at Wild Turkey. The friendly competitors augment each other’s comments and the result is an unbelievably rich experience for those of us with a greater-than-average curiosity about such things.

The tour is very much "hands-on". As we observe the mash fermenting in the cypress tanks, we’re encouraged to breath in the vapors and taste the mash itself. We can compare and see the difference only a few hours can make in the fermentation process. We are given samples of the raw white dog whiskey coming off the stills so we can experience what new bourbon whiskey looks, smells, and tastes like. As we are introduced to the fine art of barrel construction, an audience member (who just happens to be Linda) is chosen to demonstrate the art of whacking the bung into the barrel with a wooden bung hammer. Feigning concern that she might miss or not hit it hard enough, Linda suggests that John's head should be placed on the bung as a sort of guide. She swings the mallet. The imagery must have worked… she splits that bung right in two!

It is at about this point when John realizes that the batteries in his camera need to be replaced. No problem; he brought the battery charger and a bag of freshly charged batteries conveniently located... uh, well, on his dresser bureau in the bedroom at home. We are less than half an hour into an evening to remember forever and we have taken our last photograph of this trip. Oh well. You always have to leave something behind. You can bet it won't EVER be the batteries again!

After the tour we are taken to another building, where the tasting and dining area had been set up. Here the pride of both Lincoln (Woodford Reserve Distiller’s Select) and Jimmy (Russell’s Reserve) will be compared, not to determine which is "better" but to show how different two expressions of the distiller’s art can be, as well as how similar two products made with such different processes can be. The tasting is very informative, and includes important standards, such as just how much water to use to take the alcohol edge off (two parts bourbon to one part water). One thing that seems noteworthy is that neither master distiller appears to be concerned with naming specific flavors, such as fruits or spices. "Oak"iness, grain flavors, smoke, tobacco, and leather seem to be about the limit of the descriptive phrases they both use. And this is certainly not a "see the lecturer" presentation, either; this is a hands-on tasting for which we are provided with generous samples of each bourbon and a glass of water.

After the tasting the gourmet dinner is presented. Served elegantly in a formal style, the meal differs from some we’ve had in that it left us feeling we’d received the full value of what we paid for. The dinner, prepared by Labrot & Graham’s own chef-in-residence David Larson, consists of:

  • Orange and Bourbon Glazed Salmon on field greens with Thyme Vinaigrette
  • Smoked Chops (Lamb, I believe) with Mint Demiglace
  • Roasted Asparagus and Corn Timbales
  • Rolls made from spent mash grain
  • Individual Whiskey Cakes, made with Woodford Reserve and filled with Caramel Mousse, served with Bourbon Custard

There are only a small number of tables, with one of the celebrities or distillery executives seated at each to share with the guests. As at Mary Bobo’s in Lynchburg (where our table’s hostess was Lynn Tolley herself), we again find ourselves in the enviable position of sharing a table with only one other guest (a knowledgeable man from Japan; unfortunately each of us believes the other has written down his name) and Lincoln Henderson. Needless to say, the conversation is awesome.

As we finish dinner, historian Sam Thomas, with the assistance of the two master distillers, presents a talk on the History of Bourbon in Kentucky. Of course, such a discussion, given at this particular location, would almost have to focus on the legend of Doctor James C. Crow, and whether he deserves the often-given title of "Father of Bourbon Whiskey". According to Sam, like all such legends, there is some truth, accompanied by what appears to be more than just a little "knowledge" of questionable merit. Sam carefully lays out some of the claims about Crow and points out discrepancies in the documented record. Of particular concern to Sam is the fact that little of what has been published about James Crow appears to have been written during his lifetime, or by people who actually knew the man. As this is very much a two-way discussion, with the guests encouraged to participate, John offers the idea that the real "Father of Bourbon" (at least of the federally-acknowledged definition of bourbon) might have been Edmund Taylor, who documented both ingredients and processes and successfully lobbied them into the Bottled-In-Bond Act. His ideas of what a "quality bourbon product" should be would have come directly from his association with James Crow, and perhaps it was THAT that raised Dr. Crow’s methods to the status of Authority. Sam entertains that idea for awhile and never really really indicates disagreement with it. It also emphasizes the direction he is illustrating.

After the discussion, Bill Creason brings the event to a close with thank yous and hints of more to come, and we head back to the motel in Lexington. Our drive back sure is a lot shorter than getting there .

Looking for more about American Whiskey?  Google  

          Contact us through 

Story and original photography copyright © 1998-2001 by John F. Lipman. All rights reserved.